Orchestral Emulation with Reverb, Panning and Chorus Controllers To emulate real orchestral ensemble performances, their characteristic physical seating arrangements must be considered. I have converted such information below into their left/right spatial position (panning), their front/back "depth" (using reverb to imply timing delays due to distance), and chorus values to indicate the balance of the parts with respect to their actual duplicate numbers. Proportional factored changes to the chorus values which keep the maximum range within the 127 range of MIDI controller values is recommended for experimenting. For example, in Orchestra 1, since their are a maximum of 15 of any one instrument (the 1st and 2nd Violins in this case), a factor up to 4 may be used which would allow a maximum factored range, from the actual values of 1 to 15, from 4 to 120. This information is meant to be used as "template" settings, with your own "aural imagination" used as the final guideline for your intended effect. Comments are welcomed. Note to Cakewalk users, templates in Cakewalk are available with similar intents, but this is the first attempt which I know of to coordinate what I believe are the most critical "nuance" controllers for realistic emulations. It should be especially noted that Volume and Note Velocity are particularily critical in producing perceived spatial effects with reverb and panning. The following information is based on graphic illustrations from the book "Musical Instruments of the World - An Illustrated Encylopedia by the Diagram Group", 1976, pages 292-295. Each value was measured from an actual scaled orchestral seating chart using an instrument's "center" position for measurement of its panning and reverb values. Orchestra 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 Emulations Panning Reverb Chorus* [Woodwinds] Piccolo 53 45 30 45 73 72 76 72 1 Flute 58 62 56 52 73 72 76 72 3 2 Oboe 70 80 65 65 73 72 76 72 3 2 2+2% Eng. Horn 56 84 69 73 73 72 76 72 1 Clarinet 50 65 75 47 90 89 76 89 3 2 Bs.Clarinet 57 58 80 41 90 89 76 89 1 Bassoon 71 80 86 65 90 89 76 89 3 2 1 C.Bassoon 81 90 90 73 90 89 76 89 1 [Brass] Horn 52 54 54 43 106 106 96 106 4 2 2 Trumpet 74 77 71 67 106 106 96 106 4 2 2 Trombone 86 93 86 80 106 106 96 106 4 Tuba 93 101 93 84 106 106 96 106 1 [Percussion] Tam-tam 69 73 73 47 119 119 114 119 1 Cymbals 75 86 82 60 119 119 114 119 2 Xylophone 82 95 90 73 119 119 114 119 1 Glock. 93 101 97 82 119 119 114 119 1 Tub.Bells 98 108 103 90 119 119 114 119 1 Side Drum 44 41 39 24 119 119 114 119 1 Bass Drum 52 50 50 30 119 119 114 119 1 Timpani 61 67 66 39 119 119 114 119 2 2 2 [Strings] Harp 4 0 0 0 124 124 124 124 2 1st Violin 25 26 22 28 64 64 64 64 15 7 3 2nd Violin 37 41 37 101 64 64 64 64 15 7 3 Viola 66 73 67 60 33 42 42 42 12 6 3 Cello 96 101 97 86 49 68 68 68 10 4 2 Double Bass 120 123 121 103 112 93 93 93 8 2 1 Harpsichord 60 0 1 NOTES: ====== *Chorus colums 1-3 refer to # of instruments for "typical" orchestras: *1=Romantic (c.1850) *2=Classical (c.1790) *3=Baroque (c.1720) %=2 Oboes plus 1 oboe d'amore and 1 oboe da caccia Benjamin Tubb brtubb@cybertron.com http://www.cybertron.com/~brtubb